In Search Of Good Food - Section Navigation

Does Good Food Have To Be Organic?

Or does it just pile on the pounds?

Page 1 | 2 | 3

Are you sitting comfortably? Now define in your best GCSE answer style what is meant by 'organic farming'. It could go something like this:

Organic Farming Is...

Organic farming is a holistic approach to food production, making use of crop rotation, environmental management and good animal husbandry to control pests and diseases. Processed organic foods use ingredients that were produced organically and organic ingredients must make up at least 95% of the food.

Well, that's as clear as mud. What's not so obvious is why organic food can often cost three times as much as conventional food - in real terms, that's 60p for an organic apple versus an ordinary Golden Delicious at 19p. Crunch!

With supermarkets increasingly stocking organic food and making it more the norm to buy it, are we simply being guilt-tripped into joining the eco-friendly bandwagon and spending 63% more on our grocery shopping as a result?

As more people buy organic, more questions are rightly being raised about its true value. The strange thing is, we bet that if one of your more memorable gourmet moments was - enjoying an alfresco meal of the freshest, most fragrant sea bass baked over fresh fennel; or watching your kids' faces of pure red-stained pleasure as they hoovered up Grandma's home-grown raspberries, you wouldn't be thinking - "hang on, was all that delicious food organic?..." It really wouldn't matter.

"...Organic out-of-season produce has been flown halfway around the world..."

Does Good Food Have To Be Organic? (cont..)

Page 1 | 2 | 3

The pro and anti argument is certainly heating up fast. In 2006 the organic industry rose by 30 percent to 1.6 billion pounds. As viewpoints and statistics fly in from all sorts of governmental and scientific quarters - us normal foodies try and make up our own minds, and ultimately, let our wallets and taste buds be the deciding factor.

One of the many 'anti' debates is, that if organic out-of-season produce has been flown halfway round the world, packaged to death to avoid it looking travel-weary on arrival, where's the 'green' benefit? Give us fresh-out-of-bed conventional potatoes from the local farm over their organic equivalents who've been clocking up global warming air miles.

And the persuasive healthy eating argument swings both ways too. Tests by the Pesticide Residues Committee (PRC) suggest that choosing organic carrots is not going to help you avoid that many pesticides. Many people however, swear organic carrots taste sweeter and a little less like bland cardboard. On the pro-organic side of the fence, a study carried out by the soil association (which campaigns for sustainable agriculture and organic food), discovered that produce grown without pesticides generally contains higher levels of vitamin C and essential minerals.

Do you think choosing organic is worth it?

Does Good Food Have To Be Organic? (cont..)

Page 1 | 2 | 3

Some items in our grocery baskets are undoubtedly worth the
additional expenditure of buying organic.

And surely, the supremo example of when organic is best, must be the taste of an organically grown chicken reared on a natural, additive-free diet scratching around the farmyard; versus the bland, often fishy flavour of a cooped-up battery hen stuffed with hormone-laden fishmeal. No contest. Organic wins every time.

And here are some more surprising facts: organic doesn't always have to cost more. You can actually find organic cherry tomatoes sold in supermarkets which are cheaper than the standard variety.

So do you think choosing organic is worth it? Would you ensure your family only eats food that begins with an 'O'? It's a debate that regularly crops up in government and on the news - and more recently, right here on the Forum. Tell us what you think. Find out where others might have found the cheapest organic food that wasn't grown in their own vegetable garden!

For the record, our standpoint is that - all food should be good food, organic or not. If it tastes delicious, looks apetising and makes you feel healthy, thats good enough for us foodies. And if that food has been grown locally on well-nurtured soil, by a farmer who respects the land and the produce grown on it - even better.

have your say


search
hide search

Filtered search: Use this to filter your results and only search certain areas

Only search within food news
Only search within recipes
Only search feature articles
Only search our forums
Search everything
show or hide advanced search
Quick Poll
It’s worth paying more for organic salmon
40.8% agree
41%
agree
59.2% Disagree
59%
Disagree