In Search Of Good Food - Section Navigation

Foods friends and foods that fight

Page 1 | 2 | 3   

How about a delicious bit of salmon poached with liquorice. Nice or nasty? Or caviar and white chocolate followed by grain-mustard ice cream?

Safe in the Michelin starred hands of Heston Blumenthal, many foodies would jump at the chance to sample food combinations as weird as these. But for how long will they be considered strange? Molecular gastronomy cooking methods such as ‘liquid nitrogen’, and arranged food marriages made in test tubes are pushing the boundaries of taste expectations. Dishes like the ones featured on the Fat Duck’s Tasting Menu may one day seem as normal as cheese and grapes, or lamb and redcurrant jelly.

Eating is a multi-sensory experience. 75% of what we taste comes from smell

The way we taste food is actually quite a complicated mix of the physical (taste buds) and the psychological (our perception of food). And some foods are naturally more chemically compatible than others.

Taste receptors on the tongue are not affected by temperature, or the heat sensation of chilli pepper. But aroma, which is sensed in the nose, is strongly affected by food temperature because it depends on the release of volatile oils. So the higher the temperature, the more volatiles are released, the stronger the smell and the resulting sensation of flavour.

Researchers have caused quite a stir recently regarding the theory of the five basic tastes: sweet, sour, bitter, salty, and the lesser known one – umami, otherwise known as the monosodium glutamate receptor. There's an argument brewing that fat should also be classified as a ‘taste’. This information will undoubtedly inspire the way chefs combine and flavour their dishes, educating and surprising our palate in the process.

Some food combinations are the fashion faux pas equivalent of wearing socks with sandals

It’s surprising how many terms and phrases are shared by clothes and food, e.g – dressing the salad; wrapping chicken in Parma ham; top and tailing the beans. Extending the analogy further, a wardrobe of clothes and accessories that mix and match to suit the occasion and the weather, is the equivalent of having store cupboard full of essentials that work as well for a dinner party menu as they do for a packed lunch.

We ‘eat’ with the eye first, so choose a colour scheme that works

Factors to consider when putting foods together for a meal that tastes as good as it looks are: colour, variety, size, texture and temperature. A lot of this is common sense, but as a general rule of thumb - complementary colours work better than the same colours side by side. Psychologically they have an effect too. Bland-coloured meat or fish is enhanced with a bit of vibrant tomato or pepper relish. Topping carrots or mashed potatoes with a knob of butter or flecks of chopped parsley adds an appetising colour contrast



If one food is very bland, add some life and variety with something spicy next to it

Page 1 | 2 | 3   

Different sizes, shapes, proportions and textures in food will not only be more visually interesting, they will appeal to the taste buds too. The shape of food tends to work better if it’s complimentary, rather than uniform in appearance. Which means a plate of long, narrow foods such as, French fries, string beans and frankfurters could look a bit, well – long. And when serving something smooth and soft such as soup or a creamy pudding, it’s good to add a counter-accent with something crunchy like a crisp salad, crusty rolls or crumbly biscuits.

“While a plain-tasting food can be superbly set off with a tangy sauce, aim for a homogeneous meal. It usually works better than a hodgepodge of different cultures on a plate. So if you’re cooking Indian, make all the courses Indian. And unless you’re being deliberately experimental, don’t serve pasta with chicken curry, or moussaka with Thai noodles.”

The temperature of food is another consideration. Convention and cultural preferences aside, the flavour of foods that have little natural smell, are enhanced by heating; whereas foods with strong aromas like smoked fish, may become overpowering at high temperatures. So be wary about which cold and hot foods can happily share a plate – “sizzling fajitas with cold potato salad anyone?”

Pair up a wine and food from the same region and you’ll be on the right track

What food goes with what wine is another common conundrum. Get the right balance of 'weight' between food and wine, so that neither overpowers the other, and you’ll have a lovely meal. However, serving a heavy French red wine with seafood would completely dominate the delicate flavours of the dish. And a rich, meaty stew would drown out the bouquet of a neutral white wine.

Does the ‘two ingredients are company but three are incompatible’ formula really work?

There’s another interesting theory on the table at the moment – The Incompatible Food Triad problem. The definition reads like something off a school maths paper, but essentially it’s this:

Three different spices or other main ingredients do not go together in some recipes, yet any pair of them is fine. Discuss…

An example of this “going together” theory is: chocolate, chicken and honey. This gives us the delicious sounding honey-butter chicken; a Mexican dish of chicken with chocolate sauce and all kinds of desserts made with chocolate and honey. But…chocolate-honey chicken sounds, and probably is, revolting.

Another 3-food incompatibility combo could be: potatoes, mayonnaise and cabbage. If you can think of any others, post them here on the forum. This theory could at any rate, make for an interesting new game to break the ice at dinner parties.



The controversial food fight continues with the controversial Hay diet

Page 1 | 2 | 3   

Moving on from friend and foe food combinations to the food combining diet many swear by – the Hay phenomenon. It’s commonly believed that the human stomach is well adapted to digest any number of different foods at the same time. Since 1911 the early pioneer, Dr William Hay couldn’t disagree more. A deluge of diet books eulogizing his beliefs then followed his theory.

Food combining, often referred to as the Hay diet, is one of the few dieting methods that most health and fitness specialists recommend, simply because there is little chance of adverse effects such as headaches or nausea. And it has been shown to help people with food intolerances, digestive and weight problems,

The Hay diet is about avoiding eating certain foods together because this is supposedly bad for your digestion

Protein needs an acidic environment to be digested properly, so the theory suggests that meat shouldn’t be eaten together with starchy foods that require an alkaline environment. The easiest way to practice the programme is to have one meal each day, which is protein with salads or vegetables, and another meal, which is carbohydrate, with vegetables and salad.

“In some cases, combining certain foods does enhance the absorption of nutrients. For example, eating oranges (high in vitamin C) with steak helps to increase the absorption of iron from the meat.”

One of the main problems with the Hay diet is that a protein-only meal or a carbohydrate-only meal can be very unsatisfying and leave you craving for more. Plus, this system can be deficient in nutrients, including calcium, zinc, and vitamins D and B12.

Some foods eaten together could help fight cancer

Of course, food combining isn’t just about the Hay diet. On a more positive note, researchers have shown that eating certain foods together, such as chicken and broccoli or salmon and watercress could help fight cancer. It’s to do with the two nutrients called sulforaphane and selenium, which make the foods up to 13 times more powerful in attacking cancer together than they are alone. The discovery could mean it could be possible to design special cancer-fighting foods or diets in the future.

Discover food harmony for inner peace, Virudha ahar style

As ancient alternative therapies go, Virudha ahar, or ‘Antagonistic food material’ to give its slightly more scary-sounding title, isn’t a bad one. In a spiritual nutshell, it believes that to keep a balanced mind in a balanced body, good food is of utmost importance. Incompatible foods are called virudha-ahar and by combining different types of food one can turn healthy foods to unhealthy ones and unhealthy foods to healthy ones.

So have you been pleasantly surprised or surprisingly disappointed by unexpected food combinations you’ve come across? Do you believe that certain foods will always ‘fight’ each other and by eating them you’ll pay the price with your health? Or, maybe like all good relationships in life, you think a little bit of conflict keeps things interesting? Feel free to stand your corner with your point of view on the forum.



search
hide search

Filtered search: Use this to filter your results and only search certain areas

Only search within food news
Only search within recipes
Only search feature articles
Only search our forums
Search everything
show or hide advanced search
Quick Poll
Paying more for one key ingredient in a recipe, makes a noticeable difference to the taste.
63.1% agree
63%
agree
36.9% Disagree
37%
Disagree